Never Let Me Go

Young British Actors

Here’s an interestingly subdued take on the sci-fi genre, adapted by Alex Garland from Kazuo Ishiguro’s novel of the same name. The setting is the recent past; Carey Mulligan, Andrew Garfield and Keira Knightly play three friends who grow up together at the secluded Hailsham boarding school – a breeding ground, we soon discover, for organ-donor clones, who will only live to their mid-twenties in order to keep the rest of the world healthy.

These unnerving circumstances are, however, merely background to the simple love-triangle that is at the film’s heart. Whilst the odd detail – the LED bleep of an electronic chip reader – tells us this isn’t life as we know it, director Mark Romanek is more interested in the bleak faces of his actors and lingering shots of mundane hospital exteriors or grey, deserted beaches.

It’s a gentle, ordinary world in which sci-fi won’t often be found, but – as with Ishiguro’s writing – there’s much that bubbles just under the surface. Romanek demonstrates the economy with which cinema can communicate ideas and conjure worlds: we briefly see, for instance, the pitiless way in which doctors handle Garfield’s body on the operating table as his general anaesthetic kicks in, hinting at the full, brutal horror that remains, for the most part, beyond the screen.

Presumably taken straight from Ishiguro’s novel, the deceptive banality of phrases such as ‘donation’, ‘deferral’ and – most unnervingly – ‘completion’ cause us to consider how language can conceal, bringing to my mind the dark satire of Monkey Dust’s marketing gurus rebranding cancer as ‘closure’. And there are fissures in this sheen of euphemism and complacency – in the middle of nothing, we’ll suddenly hear chilling mention of schools ‘like battery farms’.

If it feels slightly frustrating that the film doesn’t want to pursue these elements any further, perhaps that’s the point. Everything is very restrained and accepting, very polite, very English. The acting, by Garfield and Mulligan especially, is intelligent and heartfelt, but what’s most disquieting is that none of these characters summon any real resistance to their fate. Somehow the morality of the film’s donor-clone premise is brought into focus precisely by not being challenged in the plot itself: are these individuals really happy to sacrifice themselves for others? Have they been brainwashed by society? Or perhaps denied to the opportunity to develop a life-drive that would make them truly human?

This entry was posted in Films. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Never Let Me Go

  1. PZL says:

    I thought the review in The Times Culture mag of this film as ‘mind-numbingly boring’ (or whatever it was) was very harsh – as you’ve written here, the film is purposefully restrained and subtle, and as a result is more effective in its chillingness. If this was an American blockbuster the characters would have mounted an attack against the State with explosions, espionage, and overwrought dialogue: how obvious, repetitive and (really) much less realistic.

    I thought this film was entertaining, beautiful, highly emotional, and thought-provoking – not sure what else is required for a piece of cinema?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s